The Departed
The Descent
Children of Men
Casino Royale
Blood Diamond
Honorable Mention: Marie Antoinette, Black Dahlia, The Illusionist, Thank You For Smoking, and Pirates of the Caribbean 2: Dead Man's Chest.
And with slots preserved for The Prestige, Babel, and The Painted Veil, which I anticipate being good, but have not yet seen.
I've been waiting to see Children of Men, it seems very promising. Hopefully this weekend.
And yes, The Prestige I'm sure will make it to your list.
I'm scared of Blood Diamond though, it'll make me feel sad/bad I'm sure. *whimper*
The Prestige is awwwesome. Loved Casino Royale. Liked Pirates2. Want to see the rest on your list!